SATA vs. NVMe: Top 10 Comparisons

Thanks to its affordability and SSD support, serial advanced technology attachment (SATA) is a popular connectivity mechanism for internal and external storage drives. In contrast, non-volatile memory express (NVMe) is a connectivity interface purpose-built for SSD – promising high performance but at a higher cost. This article explains the meaning of SATA and NVMe, and how they differ from each other. 

What Is SATA?

SATA, also known as serial advanced technology attachment (ATA), is an interface for transferring data between a computer’s central circuit board and storage devices, which can be internal (such as hard disc drives and solid state drives) or external (such as a redundant array of independent disks or RAID arrays). Importantly, serial communication sends data one bit at a time, unlike several parallel streams, which is one of SATA’s central features.

SATA has now supplanted the previously popular PATA or parallel ATA interface. It is the most prevalent storage interface used by most consumer-grade hard drives. Since 2003, when Intel developed and released SATA, it has been the preferred method for attaching an HDD to a laptop or desktop computer.

How does SATA work?

The SATA 1.0 standard was published for the first time in August 2001 as an alternative to the parallel ATA interface used by IBM-compatible systems. Each drive inside a disc array can receive 1.5 Gbps capacity through SerialATA. It is interoperable with other PATA devices and includes a thin, compact cable option. 

Compared to the older ribbon connection cables used with ATA drives, this cable facilitates easier cable routing and improves computer ventilation.

The key features of SATA are:

• Works on a low-voltage connection: SATA’s signal is 500mV (0.5V) peak-to-peak. This contributes to a reduction in distortion and crosstalk between wires.
• Utilizes differential signaling: Differential signaling is a method that concurrently transmits both in- and out-of-phase signals via two neighboring lines. By identifying the phase variation between the two signals at the receiver’s end, it is feasible to transport high-speed data with a minimal operational voltage and reduced power consumption.
• Uses a relatively simple cable construction: PATA cables were constructed using a 40-pin/80-wire ribbon cable, which was an intricate construction. SATA, in contrast, consists of a single 7-pin data line plus a 15-pin cable connection. This increases the signaling rate, which results in quicker data throughput.
• Enables fast data transfers: The data transmission rate of SATA is 150, 300, or 600 MB every second. This feature of SATA allows quicker program loading, improved image loading, and rapid document loading.

External SATA, more often known as eSATA, provides support for external drives through designated plug-in zones called SATA ports. 

eSATA has several benefits when compared to other options. It is hot-swappable, provides greater transfer rates without bottleneck concerns (as in the case of USB and FireWire), and is compatible with disc drive technologies. One may link a single eSATA connector to an external SATA box to extend storage and construct RAID storage arrays. Typical uses for eSATA drives include video editing, audio creation, and data backup.

However, eSATA has some limitations, such as not transmitting power over cables like USBs. This means that it will require additional power sources for drives.

See More: What Is NAS (Network Attached Storage)? Working, Features, and Use Cases

What Is NVMe?

Non-volatile memory express (NVMe) is a computer storage interface that utilizes the peripheral component interconnect express (PCIe) bus to transmit data at high speeds to and from solid-state drives (SSDs). The higher speed and latency of the PCI Express bus make it a prime candidate for replacing SATA, serial-attached small computer systems interface (SCSI) or SAS for storage interoperability.

NVMe technology was launched in 2011 to overcome the limitations of SATA interfaces and network protocols. It employs the PCIe bus instead of the SATA bus to unleash the considerable bandwidth potential of storage devices. PCIe 4.0 (the current version) supports up to 32 lanes and can theoretically transport data at speeds of up to 64,000MB/s, compared to SATA III’s maximum transfer rate of 600MB/s.

Additionally, the NVMe standard permits 65535 command queues. This presents enormous possibilities for storage devices by enhancing their efficiency, reliability, and interoperability across various platforms.

How does NVMe work?

Because they were intended for use with sluggish/slower HDDs and tape-based memory, legacy storage connectivity interfaces such as SAS and SATA generate congestion in modern networks. NVMe is meant to use the higher speed and parallel processing capability of solid-state drive (SSD) memory.

This technology can deliver much higher speeds because:

• Performs input/output (I/O) activities in parallel with multicore CPUs to achieve high throughput.
• Instead of passing via the SAS or SATA controller, it directly interacts with the host CPU.
• Has multiple command queues and, therefore, can transmit multiple commands per queue.
• Reduces latency to lesser than three microseconds by using fewer CPU cycles.
• Supports SSDs with a range of non-volatile memory (NVM) types.

The key features that enable the working of NVMe are:

• Minimizes driver customization needs: Earlier PCIe-connected SSDs required individual device drivers for all operations. If a user upgraded the operating system or simply installed a security patch, it was often necessary to deploy an entirely new device driver to access SSDs. NVMe SSDs are supported out of the box by the most prevalent operating systems and hypervisors. Given that the interface is standardized, any NVMe SSD built by any manufacturer can be supported by a single device driver.
• Captures asynchronous events: The NVMe protocol also allows asynchronous events, such as self-monitoring, analysis, and reporting technology (SMART) status checks, error reporting, firmware commits, sanitization, etc. These are essential for hosts to comprehend, respond to, and seize command of the gadget, as and when necessary. These events are neither instantly executable nor do they expire. Additionally, the host may execute asynchronous firmware upgrades and make them accessible at a specific period.
• Streamlines the booting process: NVMe specifications define a boot partition that is ready to be read well before the controller is operational. Even programs needed to boot to a pre-OS state, like a unified extensible firmware interface (UEFI), may be included in the partition area. This option is also beneficial for secure booting.

SATA vs. NVMe: Top 10 Comparisons

It is important to note that both SATA and NVMe are used in SSD environments, but only the latter is purpose-built for SSDs. Along with this, there are several differences between SATA and NVMe: 

1. Interface type

As mentioned, a solid-state drive (SSD) uses either non-volatile memory express (NVMe) or serial advanced technology attachment (SATA) to communicate with the rest of the computer. NVMe is a host controller interface designed to accelerate the data transfer rate between enterprise and client systems over a computer’s PCIe bus. The PCIe component ensures lower latency and higher input/output operations per second (IOPS). Thus, NVMe reads and accesses data faster than SATA.

On the other hand, SATA drives access data through the advanced host controller interface (AHCI). AHCI speeds up mechanical drives and enables hot-swapping to be performed by using the native command queuing (NCQ) feature. SATA is backward and forward-compatible with all SATA standards but is an entirely different interface from NVMe.

2. Speed

NVMe drives have higher and faster transfer rates even when both SATA and NVMe drives are in a single form factor. 

To illustrate, a third-generation NVMe PCIe connector 3.0 can reach a maximum speed of up to 3,500 MB/s, while a fourth-generation NVMe PCIe connector 4.0 reaches speeds of up to 7,500MB/s. In contrast, SATA drives have relatively slower transfer rates. A SATA SSD can reach speeds of up to 500MB/s, while a SATA HDD can reach speeds of up to 160MB/s. Individual SATA models also have different performance speeds. However, these speeds may suffice for consumer-grade use, which requires a fraction of the power necessary in supercomputing.

In SSDs, the transfer rate also depends on the individual model and the drive’s PCIe connector generation. The speed of a drive affects tasks such as editing documents, web browsing, loading files, and copying files.

3. Form factors and physical appearance

NVMe SSDs are commonly found in pre-built desktop computers and laptops in the M.2 form factor (a specification defined for internally mounted computer cards). Other forms, such as the U.2, U.3, and enterprise and data center standard form factor (EDSFF), exist but are less common in NVMe. 

In contrast, SATA SSDs are either available in the form of the standard 2.5-inch or the small and slimmer M.2 drives. The 2.5-inch form factor is the most commonly found form of SATA SDDs, while the M.2 SATA SSDs are primarily found in tablets, minicomputers, and ultrathin laptops.

4. Differences in pricing

In general, NVMe SSDs are more expensive than SATA SSDs. Even when both NVMe and SATA drives have the same storage capacities, NVMe drives cost more. 

The cost of a 250GB NVMe SSD storage space ranges from $50 to $90, a 500GB one from $70 to $160, and a 1TB storage from $120 to $200. Additionally, NVMe SSDs with higher speeds cost more. The price of a 1TB NVMe PCIe 3.0 ranges from $115 to $120, while that of a 1TB NVMe PCIe 4.0 ranges from $120 to $200.

SATA SSDs are cheaper and more affordable than NVMe drives. The price of a 250GB SATA drive ranges from $40 to $70, a 500GB one from $50 to $90, and a 1TB one from $90 to $140.

Speed and storage capacity are the primary determinants of price in SSDs. Faster drives are costlier, drives with larger capacities cost more, and some SSD models cost more than others. 

5. Approaches to power management

NVMe drives are more power-efficient and eco-friendly than SATA drives. NVMe SSDs use semiconductor modules to store and access data, thus significantly reducing power consumption. The average power consumed by a standby NVMe SSD is 0.0032 W, while that of an active NVMe is 0.08 W. 

Additionally, NVMe SSDs can recognize IO patterns to determine temperature changes. This ability enables them to flexibly allocate more power efficiently to write-intensive workloads and less energy to read-dominated workloads. SSDs with low power usage generate lower heat which is an ideal solution for denser servers and storage devices.

SATA SSDs use more power, with the average power consumption rate of a standby SATA being 0.195 W, while that of an in-use SATA is 0.279 W. 

See More: What Is a Computer Network? Definition, Objectives, Components, Types, and Best Practices 

6. Security mechanisms

Due to increased cyber threats, the need to store and access data securely has been a significant concern for anyone looking for storage media. NVMe drives provide better encryption than SATA drives. NVMe SSDs use the XTS-AES 256-bit encryption standard to secure user data. AES-256 encryption is undecipherable, making it the favored method of securing private data from cyber attacks.  

Moreover, NVMe integrates with security management solutions offered by encryption providers like McAfee and Symantec. NVMe SSD also has additional security features, such as lockdown 2.0, which enables administrators to allow users to read and write data on parts of the drive while disabling other features to prevent users from making unintended changes to the drive. 

Additionally, NVMe SSD has the transport layer security (TLS) protocol that encrypts data and authenticates connections between computers. In contrast, SATA SSDs have very few security mechanisms – you can only use erase and sanitize commands to protect the storage remotely.

7. Command queue

SSDs that handle more command queues are essential for users and enterprises that require multitasking. 

NVMe architecture supports 65,535 input/output (I/O) command queues, each supporting 65,535 commands simultaneously. NVMe has a non-uniform memory access (NUMA) feature that allows multiple cores to share ownership of queues. It also enables the creation of an unlimited number of queues to meet the expected workload. On the other hand, SATA SSDs only have a single queue with 32 commands per queue.

Further, IOPS is a crucial performance indicator for enterprises and hosting service providers when retrieving multiple files at a given time. For enterprises, their storage media must have a high IOPS to maintain high performance to handle many consumers accessing the software program that ties to an extensive data warehouse. NVMe drives generally have a higher IOPS as they push out at speeds of over 1,500,000 on both read and write, while SATA drives top out at around 75,000 read IOPS.

8. Use cases

The choice to use either an NVMe SSD or SATA SSD will vary between individual and business use. For personal use, a SATA SSD represents the value-for-money option. It offers affordable cheap storage for storing several files and allows users to perform various functions at high speeds.

It is also backward compatible and thus can be used with legacy components. Unlike an NVMe SSD, it will not stress other motherboard components, such as processors with low processing capabilities.

For business use, such as in enterprises and hosting solutions, NVMe SSD is the preferred option. Further, business-critical applications require high IOPS to handle several requests simultaneously to ensure a smooth user experience. As a result, online stores may use NVMe SSDs as their preferred storage media. 

NVMe is also valuable for enterprises that require transaction-heavy databases, such as financial institutions.

9. Differences in their key focus 

The main advantage of having an NVMe over a SATA drive is speed. The maximum speed of an NVMe SSD is astonishingly over ten times more than that of a SATA SSD. When this NVMe SSD is paired with other high-end motherboards, the computer can achieve blazing-fast speeds. 

The main focus of a SATA SSD is to strike a good balance between speed and affordability. While its top speed of up to 500MB/S may not seem like much compared to that of an NVMe drive, that speed is sufficiently high for a typical user. A SATA SSD allows users to experience a better and more affordable performance from their computers while saving costs.

10. Business vs. consumer use

Over the years, SSDs have become less costly, with more manufacturing entrants into the storage market. However, NVMe costs remain prohibitively high even for the same storage capacity as SATA. Further, despite high prices, purchasing an NVMe SSD does not necessarily guarantee better performance unless you are a business user with supporting equipment.

On the other hand, SATA SSDs are unsuitable for use in environments requiring fast data transfers and low latency rates. This is due to their significantly low IOPS, which cannot manage critical applications efficiently. Additionally, their power inefficiency makes them less eco-friendly and costlier to maintain for businesses when compared to NVMe SSDs. 

See More: LTE vs. 4G: Understanding The 8 Key Differences

Takeaway

SATA remains the default standard for SSD-based storage, at least in consumer-grade computing. As technology becomes more efficient and cheaper, manufacturers are slowly slashing prices on their NVMe offerings to increase market adoption. A price gap may exist today, but eventually, NVMe is poised to become the norm due to its security and speed advantages.

Did this article help you understand how SATA differs from NVMe? Tell us on FacebookOpens a new window , TwitterOpens a new window , and LinkedInOpens a new window . We’d love to hear from you! 

MORE ON HARDWARE

• What Is Network Hardware? Definition, Architecture, Challenges, and Best Practices
• Switch vs. Router: Understanding 15 Key Comparisons
• What Is NAS (Network Attached Storage)? Working, Features, and Use Cases
• What Is Raspberry Pi? Models, Features, and Uses
• What Is IT Infrastructure? Definition, Building Blocks, and Management Best Practices